← The Archive
Daily Find · November 16, 2026

It's Not the Biggest Day

Internet & Bizarro
A sidewalk sign outside an Intertoys shop in Rotterdam reading Black Friday, Cyber Monday, 50% off

Cyber Monday is two weeks out. It was invented in 2005 by a retail trade group that admitted, in print, it wasn't the biggest online shopping day. Last year it was.

Cyber Monday is two weeks out, and there is a date for when somebody made it up: November 2005. A retail trade group called Shop.org sat in a room trying to give online stores their own Black Friday. According to BusinessWeek's reporting that year, they threw out "Black Monday" (too close to Black Friday), "Blue Monday" (not cheery) and "Green Monday" (too environmentalist), and settled on Cyber. The press release went out on November 21, describing the Monday after Thanksgiving as "one of the biggest online shopping days of the year."

Shop.org's executive director, Scott Silverman, told BusinessWeek the quiet part. "It's not the biggest day," he said. "But it was an opportunity to create some consumer excitement." One of his own members, the CEO of the online jeweler Ice.com, said that on that Monday "we didn't notice anything special." The busiest online day of the year was usually a Monday or Tuesday in December, a week or two before Christmas week.

The press ran with it anyway. The New York Times explained the name as millions of otherwise productive Americans, back from a long weekend of window shopping, returning to high-speed connections at work and buying what they liked. Nobody had a number for that. It sounded right, and by 2010 the UK and Germany had imported it. Rotterdam has it on a sidewalk sign now.

A sidewalk sign outside an Intertoys shop in Rotterdam reading Black Friday, Cyber Monday, 4 dagen lang 50% korting
Intertoys, Rotterdam, 2018. Photo: Donald Trung Quoc, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Argentina's own CyberMonday ran three days earlier this month, November 2 to 4, with close to 800 companies under the Cámara Argentina de Comercio Electrónico. Nobody there is asking whether the Monday after Thanksgiving was ever special. It isn't their Thanksgiving.

Meanwhile the invented day came true. In 2016 Adobe's numbers had it as the biggest single day in online commerce, and last December Adobe counted $14.25 billion in U.S. online spending on Cyber Monday 2025, a record. Silverman has since called the whole thing a self-fulfilling prophecy.

It's the biggest day now. They said so first.